Fine print, Living with credit

Is having good credit overrated?

Connie Prater

What is the value of good credit? If you’re like the majority of Americans who rely on having good credit scores to help smooth the way when you buy a car, get a mortgage or apply for other types of loans, a high credit score is vitally important.

A conversation with someone at a dinner party over the weekend and recent comments from a friend makes me wonder whether the number of people who don’t value good credit is growing.
The person at the dinner party proudly revealed that he doesn’t have any credit cards (he uses debit cards if he has to book an airline flight) and pays cash for everything, including cars.

He says the last time he checked his credit score was several years ago and it was 540 back then. Credit scores range from 300 to a maximum of 850, so he was on the lower end of the range. These days, you need a FICO score of about 750 or more to get the best mortgage rates. He has no idea what his score is now. But he says it doesn’t matter to him. He is a computer programming entrepreneur and, I’m assuming, does very well.

I told him I thought he was definitely in the minority in the country because the rest of us (me included) want to be able to borrow if we need it. Since I’m not independently wealthy with my own unlimited stash of cash, I have to rely on banks to finance big-ticket items. Those banks use credit ratings to weed out the good versus bad credit risks among us. I don’t make the rules, but I’m forced to play by them because I’m not wealthy.

The discourse reminded me of a recent article about so-called “strategic defaulters.” These are people who are walking away from mortgages even though they have the ability to pay their loans. (Many are upside down with their loans, meaning they owe more on the home loans than the properties are worth.)

As the article points out, Experian and other credit reporting agencies are developing models to help banks determine which borrowers are likely to deliberately default. Doing so means these property owners will damage their credit scores, but the threat of having bad credit has not deterred them.

Check the credit repair forums and with any credit counseling agency and you’ll find thousands of people trying to find ways to boost their credit scores. Yet some people are snubbing their noses at the whole credit reporting system. Why?

How bad is bad credit?
A friend who spent several years working for a bankruptcy law firm and talking to people before, during and after their bankruptcy filings, explains it this way:

“The importance of good credit is tied to how severe the consequence is of bad credit, and, with proper planning, the effect of bad credit can be mitigated in five years, which means good credit is overrated just like a college education and home ownership. That’s not to say there is no value, it’s just a value that is exaggerated.”

He adds: “The value of good credit is the savings derived from lower interest rates one can derive on loans for a fixed period of time. The fixed period of time component is critical because time heals bad credit scores, and at a rate faster than most people realize.”

“A major reason good credit is so overrated is that with proper planning the effect of bankruptcy on a credit rating can be to a large extent mitigated within five years, even though it does stay on your [credit report] for 10 years. The banks promote, and most people believe, that a bankruptcy is much worse for your good credit than what most Americans face, heavy debt leverage, and often that may not be true.”

I value my friend’s opinions. He has clearly spent time analyzing the pros and cons and costs and benefits of bad credit and came up with these conclusions. For me, I’m still paying my bills on time to keep my good credit score and pay my financial obligations.

I wanted to write this blog to find out how many other people there are out there who feel that having good credit isn’t that important. I also want to hear from those who’ve been rejected for loans because they had bad credit.

See related: Q&A with Adam Baker of Man Vs. Debt, Consumer credit card debt drops slightly in April, Fed says credit cards easier to get, but does anyone want one?, Angry about the credit scoring system? Here’s what to do

Join the Discussion

We encourage an active and insightful conversation among our users. Please help us keep our community civil and respectful. For your safety, we ask that you do not disclose confidential or personal information such as your bank account numbers, social security numbers, etc. Keep in mind that anything you post may be disclosed, published, transmitted or reused.

The editorial content on is not sponsored by any bank or credit card issuer. The journalists in the editorial department are separate from the company's business operations. The comments posted below are not provided, reviewed or approved by any company mentioned in our editorial content. Additionally, any companies mentioned in the content do not assume responsibility to ensure that all posts and/or questions are answered.

  • Chris Byknish

    I had always worried about having a good credit rating – being financially responsible – secure – being able to get loans when needed – I did have a very good credit score – bought my first house with 30% down (in cash) – paid off my first new car in 2 yrs – had extra money and did not spend a lot on extravagance – then I got married (bad choice) and got DV’d (best thing) – unfortunatley, he had nothing (& was married b-4 with 3 kids and an ex b&t<$) who took him to court all the time – so, he felt I “owed” him because I “had” and he “had not” – I was married for 4 yrs and it took 3 yrs to get DV – and he got from me also – My credit rating was ruined (he was diag with cancer, had surgery – did not work, and they took 1/2 – yes %50% of my take home pay, for him – so I could not pay all my bills – after that, something that was NOT of my own making – and dealing with everything – my attitude has CHANGED ! – I am still careful – but if I forget to pay my utilities for a month – or something – I really doesn’t matter as much – I had it worse and survived – my credit is getting back – but my DV was final in 2005 – and I still had to pay the bills and live – I am spending more on me cos I deserve it at this stage of the game (and my life, I am 53) – I have 2 credit cards that were never abused – I buy / I pay – and use the debit – also do the 6 mo or 12 mo SAC – if I don’t have the money, or can’t afford to in a time period, I don’t buy – but do I strive for a perfect or great credit score – NO – cos it can be taken away, by something or someone and it is NOT your fault – but – THEY don’t care – so, they affected me also !

  • Susan F

    Time may heal bad credit, but it’s expensive and handicapping while you have it.

  • Chris, It’s true that bad things happen to good people’s credit ratings. I’m thinking of all of the people who are victims of ID theft and end up being hounded for debts they don’t owe. Nothing worse than paying off a debt that’s not yours just to clear your credit report of negative information so that you can get that car loan or mortgage that you want.

  • it is overrated.

  • SarahLindsay

    Why can’t someone change the way bad credit is allowed to destroy your life.This country worship
    credit more than they worship God.Somethings in life happens that we have no control over.Banks
    or whatever the case may be if they ain’t careful
    sure enough,they are not going to have any customers.Really who have good credit these days.They probably don’t have it themselves.

  • cheez

    The whole credit rating process is biased. It is slated towards the lenders. In other words, a good credit rating depends on you being IN DEBT, but making on-time payments etc. So if I have a nice 401K portfolio, if I invest in stocks, if I have a nice sized emergency fund, but I am not paying for a car, don’t have a mortgage, and only have a debit card,guess what? My FICO score won’t be that high..I am living testimony of that. So I would have to go OWE someone money, and then make timely payments, including interest payments, just so I can go borrow more for the big ticket items…

  • Anonymous

    It really do matters as they were banks and some lending agency that will refer to your credit history to help them determine which borrowers are likely to deliberately failing.