Living with credit, Protecting yourself, Research, regulation, industry reports

Credit report errors hamper health insurance enrollment

Kelly Dilworth

You may have trouble getting your identity verified when you apply for health insurance through the online Federal Marketplace if there are errors on your credit report.

The government-run website uses identity-verification services provided by credit reporting agency Experian and, according to numerous reports, lots of people are having a hard time proving to the government-run site that they are who they say they are.

Got credit report errors? Good luck enrolling for health insurance

A Nov. 26 article in the New York Times tells of thousands of health insurance applicants who have so far struggled to take advantage of the new Federal Marketplace because the website couldn’t verify their identity.

In an interview with New York Times reporter Robert Pear, Joanne Peters, a spokeswoman for the Department of Health and Human Services, said that the vast majority of applicants have had no trouble breezing through the online identification process. “However, some consumers whose information does not match records, such as when an alternate name is used or an address does not match, may be referred to a call center,” said Peters.

Those call centers are run by Experian and some user reports posted online state that it may take a while to get through to a representative. Once you do, you may still not be able to get your problem rectified.

If the customer service representative is unable to verify your identity, then you’ll have to upload proof to and wait for someone to get back to you. Or you can just sign up the old-fashioned way — in person — at a “local help” site designated by and present proper identification.

An imperfect database

It’s not clear what exactly is causing so many people to run into problems when they try to get their identities verified on the website. But in a message to the consumer advocacy group Consumers Union, one consumer suggested that unresolved credit report errors could be partially to blame (at least for some unlucky applicants). In a message re-posted by Consumers Union’s Maureen Mahoney, the consumer wrote:

“Twice now, I’ve been unable to get my identity verified because Experian has had incorrect data on me in their files … [The] second was when I was trying to apply for health insurance for my husband under the new ACA website. How is it that this agency has so much power over us and isn’t forced to be more accurate or more diligent in checking its data?”

According to a December 2012 report from the Federal Trade Commission, a substantial number of errors found on credit reports involve so-called header information, such as a consumer’s age or address.

Those types of errors could potentially gum up Experian’s identity verification services, since the security questions that asks consumers to answer may involve addresses where the consumer has never lived.

Other credit errors that could theoretically cause problems include mixed file issues that involve incorrect names or Social Security numbers and even bigger problems, such as records that incorrectly show you’re dead. (Apparently, at least one Twitter user, David Tarver, has already claimed that he couldn’t get verified through because Experian thought he was six feet under.)

Tough to get fixed
According to the Federal Trade Commission, credit report errors that involve identifying header information, such as an incorrect age or address, have a higher rate of getting corrected than other types of errors when consumers initiate a formal dispute.

But when the consumer reporting agencies fail to fix a credit report error on the first try, some consumers find that getting misinformation erased from their reports can be a months-long — or even years-long — nightmare.

Last year, for example, I talked to one recent college grad who spent six years trying to get identification and tradeline errors cleared from his Experian credit report.

Another gentlemen I spoke with said each time he tried to get unfamiliar addresses erased from his report, he received letters from the credit bureau saying that it had verified the addresses, so it wouldn’t change them. After several tries, he just gave up. (It’s worth noting that these anecdotes occurred before the credit reporting agencies’ industry representative announced that credit bureaus would soon begin forwarding whatever documents consumers sent as proof of their dispute to the furnishers of the misinformation — a move that analysts expect will make it easier to get at least some types of errors resolved.)

Luckily, the Federal Marketplace is trying to get around the problem of Experian-supplied errors by giving consumers an opportunity to send proof of their identity directly to the feds. Some consumers who’ve tried, however, say the government has been slow to investigate and verify their documents, according to multiple reports.

That makes buying health insurance for 2014 a stressful ordeal for those who are trying to get covered by Jan. 1 (the day that the Affordable Care Act’s federal mandate officially becomes law). If consumers don’t get health insurance by the Fed’s shifting enrollment deadline (which currently runs through the end of March), then they could wind up with a hefty penalty — through no fault of their own.

Join the Discussion

We encourage an active and insightful conversation among our users. Please help us keep our community civil and respectful. For your safety, we ask that you do not disclose confidential or personal information such as your bank account numbers, social security numbers, etc. Keep in mind that anything you post may be disclosed, published, transmitted or reused.

The editorial content on is not sponsored by any bank or credit card issuer. The journalists in the editorial department are separate from the company's business operations. The comments posted below are not provided, reviewed or approved by any company mentioned in our editorial content. Additionally, any companies mentioned in the content do not assume responsibility to ensure that all posts and/or questions are answered.

  • free background check

    For complete peace of mind, consider subscribing to a credit monitoring service.
    There is no telling how they file this information and the amount of people who will readily have
    access. They will use their newly acquired identity to get loans, open bank accounts
    and take out mortgages.

  • Gina

    Experian is a nightmare to get your records corrected. Why is the government even using that company’s? This is not new info every one knows it can take up to 26 months just to get an address corrected. This was a study that was done not my opinion!